Got comments? Register and make some!
Written by Anthony P Stine   
Correctator
User Rating: / 4
PoorBest 

This month, The Rearguard and The Spectator debate the issue of the White House kicking out reporters from Fox “News.” Anthony argues that the issue has nothing to do with Fox being a conservative outlet but rather that Fox is a propaganda outlet for extremist political views (with evidence!).

Over the summer, President Obama made it clear to Fox “News” that they would no longer be welcome in his White House press pool. Understandably, this caused a firestorm of controversy amongst media watchdog groups and various news organizations. In response to this troublesome move, other media organizations (such as the Washington Post) informed President Obama that this move was dangerous and could have serious Constitutional ramifications for him if he persisted in keeping Fox from covering the White House. Many media voices (mostly on Fox and their supporters) have claimed that this is an unprecedented move that makes Obama look like a dictator. This move was neither unprecedented nor dictatorial—it was just clumsy.

Fox was booted out of the press pool because they are not a news outlet. News outlets don't engage in the behavior that Fox has in the past year, which includes showing spliced footage of Obama and Joe Biden from campaign rallies during the 2008 election, where they called out John McCain for claiming that the “fundamentals of the economy were strong.” Fox edited the video to make it look as if Obama and Biden said this in the present. This is not the behavior of a media outlet; instead, these actions are what you would expect from hyper-partisan talk radio—propaganda outlets.

Fox and others have claimed that the president is trying to silence conservative media criticism of his administration. That's not even the case. The Wall Street Journal, arguably a conservative news source, is represented at the White House by Jonathan Kaufman, while the Washington Times, a hard-right newspaper, is represented by Jon Ward in the press pool. The presence of Fox “News” would be akin to allowing Rush Limbaugh a presence in the press pool. Other media outlets should support this action because it does what is desperately needed: it ends the illusion that Fox is a news station.

Obama's mistake was how quickly he cut them out. It was clumsy, awkward, and looked authoritarian, which only serves to give ammunition to those who are waging a propaganda war against the Obama administration. What the president should have done is simply not call on the Fox representative at all, and place them in the back of the press pool. The White House has control over who is present in the press pool and where they sit. Eventually the White House could have simply removed the Fox representative without nearly the same level of outcry. In Fox's place the White House could have invited a representative of The American Spectator, one of the premier conservative news magazines in the country. Instead the administration acted without thinking of the consequences and has since been forced to allow the representatives of Fox back to the White House.

What Fox is guilty of is discrediting the voice of conservatism in the United States. Conservativatism has become synonymous with Fox, Rush Limbaugh, Ann Coulter, and a plethora of other clowns who contribute nothing but hate to the political discourse. Fox has done this by legitimizing all of the nonsense surrounding claims about “death panels,” forced abortions in the health care bill, the claims of Obama being a secret Kenyan Muslim, and stories about Obama having various nefarious dealings with Maoists. This isn't news. It is a slap in the face to real journalism to even call Fox a news station. In the end it's probably better for free speech to allow Fox to return to covering the White House, even if they will simply edit press conference footage to create anything they want. The good news is that Fox's ratings are in the toilet, which may force Rupert Murdoch to fire Roger Ailes (the head of Fox “News”) and make their coverage actually conservative—and actually news, instead of just more radical noise.

References:
Media Matters for America. “Hannity video switch-up is only the tip of Fox News' video-doctoring iceberg.” November 11, 2009. http://mediamatters.org/research/200911110019

Share/Save/Bookmark

Comments

Please login to post comments or replies.
 

Correctator

Sometimes the President needs a reality check.

February 2010 | Anthony P Stine

Read it!

Re-prioritizing PSU

Don’t Get Haunted by the Ghost of Glanville’s Passed.

February 2010 | Anthony P Stine

Read it!

Album Review: Devin Townsend Project, "Addicted"

A fun (and dare I say) addicting look into the confusing mind of Devin Townsend.

February 2010 | Anthony P Stine

Read it!

Life after ASPSU

Former ASPSU student leaders are trying to make an impact in the community.

February 2010 | Anthony P Stine

Read it!

There's Weed in Student Housing!

There is a 63-year-old woman who lives in Portland State University Housing, and her name is Joyce Boles. In early January 2010, Boles was arrested after Resident officials suspected her of smoking pot in her room. She’s got something to say: “College is all about ...

February 2010 | Christopher Nye

Read it!

Men's Tantric Yoga

You might be asking yourself, “Did the Rearguard just throw together an article about naked yoga so that it could make a hilarious cover?” The answer is yes, they did. You're ...

February 2010 |

Read it!

Bike Polo Bandits

PORTLAND- The sign on the fence at Arbor Lodge Park in North Portland reads: Court Reserved for Tennis Use Only: Bicycles, Skateboards and Other Uses ...

February 2010 | Matt Sixsmith

Read it!

Conan the Agrarian

On January 7th, and perhaps for some time after, NBC executives decided that they’ve gone through life long enough without having seen what the inside of their assholes look ...

February 2010 |

Read it!

God, Metal Sucks Now

Twelve years ago, Rob Halford, arguably one of the most metal gentlemen of all time, told everyone that he was gay. While there's nothing wrong with that, it didn't exactly jibe with metal’s homophobic ...

February 2010 |

Read it!

Real Porn Shop Stories

'Twas a cold, rainy September night. Portland's vegetation was stunted on account of the oppressive temperature, but the weather had no effect on commerce in east Multnomah County… the air was ripe with it. Middle-aged, chemically impaired men with unkempt facial hair flocked like swallows to the shop. Sleeping silently in their beds, the owners knew not their shop’s source of ...

February 2010 |

Read it!

Retro Movie Review: Heavyweights

If there is one thing Hollywood was really lacking in the '90s, it was movies made for little kids that loosely paralleled the ...

February 2010 |

Read it!

Breast Cancer Sells Out

Rett Mutchler fights the establishment by whining about how corporations have managed to even ruin breast ...

February 2010 | Rett Mutchler

Read it!

Debate Travel Ban

PSU’s debate team may be glowing after a string of recent victories within the Pacific Northwest, but for now it appears they’re stuck ...

February 2010 | Rett Mutchler

Read it!

Debate Tournament

The PSU debate team returned victorious from another tournament, this time from Kirkland, WA, where the PSU team won the Northwest University Eagle Invitational against teams from Oregon, Washington, and ...

February 2010 | Rett Mutchler

Read it!

Dude, like... what happens if you get caught with weed?

The Rearguard feels a responsibility to its readers. We try to provide insightful coverage of underreported issues, brilliant and discerning reviews of all things cultural, and pants-peeingly funny takes on everything deserving of ...

February 2010 | Samuel Erskine

Read it!

More in: February 2010

-
+
8

Your are currently browsing this site with Internet Explorer 6 (IE6).

Your current web browser must be updated to version 7 of Internet Explorer (IE7) to take advantage of all of template's capabilities.

Why should I upgrade to Internet Explorer 7? Microsoft has redesigned Internet Explorer from the ground up, with better security, new capabilities, and a whole new interface. Many changes resulted from the feedback of millions of users who tested prerelease versions of the new browser. The most compelling reason to upgrade is the improved security. The Internet of today is not the Internet of five years ago. There are dangers that simply didn't exist back in 2001, when Internet Explorer 6 was released to the world. Internet Explorer 7 makes surfing the web fundamentally safer by offering greater protection against viruses, spyware, and other online risks.

Get free downloads for Internet Explorer 7, including recommended updates as they become available. To download Internet Explorer 7 in the language of your choice, please visit the Internet Explorer 7 worldwide page.